Angus Moon QC successfully defended this psychiatric negligence claim (unreported, County Court at Sheffield, 9 January 2019).
The Claimant – a Consultant Radiologist – jumped from a balcony in an apparent suicide attempt and sustained serious injuries. He is now confined to a wheelchair. He alleged being let down by a number of psychiatric practitioners who, he said, had failed to admit him to hospital when he should have been admitted in light of his psychiatric state. His Honour Judge Mark Gargan dismissed the claim and found for the Defendant.
The decision serves as a reminder of the factors that are likely to sway judges when assessing lay evidence.